Natural thyroid vs synthroid

Common Questions and Answers about Natural thyroid vs synthroid

armour-thyroid

I switched three months ago to the natural compounded thyroid meds. OH MY what a difference. No more highs and lows...no more headaches. It is the first time I feel normal in over 3 years... I do not care what the studies show and I am not alone. Funny how the testing always seems to prove the synthetic meds are just as good...even better...maybe this occurrs because the test are done by the group supporting the pharma?
I am concerned about synthetics vs natural thyroid hormone debate.Let say that there is nothing in this world that didnt start out naturally up to and including the synthetic thyroid meds.Now to me I dont think it is natural to take little piggy hormones.But as we all know everyone is different. I do believe however that Deity gave us these hormones so we could help our bodies help themselves.Be it "synthetic" or "natural" hormone.
I have now started the canadian desiccated natural thyroid "thyroid". I have only been taking it for 3 days now, so not too much of a change in symptoms, but I will keep you posted. How are you since you started they new drugs?
If you can't convert the T4 to T3, you either need to take natural thyroid meds like you are doing or else supplement synthroid with a synthetic T3 med. Out of curiosity: does your primary doc instruct you to take the Natur_thryoid in a couple of doses (since the T3 in it are used by the body fairly quickly)? Also: since you have been having these recent problems, see if your primary can order thryoid blood test, specifically free T3 and free T4 in addition to TSH.
I hear that natural thyroid or dessicated thyroid (one of the popular brand is Armor) is actually a much better medication that a T4 only medication like Ultroxin. I myself want to start with it, but am looking for a doctor who I can work with on this.
I have seen many on the patient to patient thyroid community see dramatic differences from generic vs. brand-name. They may never know why. I believe to be consistent when you take your meds, how long you wait to eat afterwards, when you have your bloodraws taken and that the same mfg. makes the meds. Just my 2 cents as a patient on 75mcgs name brand Synthroid. Synthroid may give coupons/discounts on their website if that is helpful.
The use of Armour vs Synthroid or Synthroid/Cytomel combination depends on the individual that is taking the medicine. Most patients only need Synthroid since the body converts T4 to T3. In some cases, like myself, Synthroid/Cytomel combination works the best since I'm having a hard time with the conversion.
How many of you out there are taking Synthroid everyday for their thyroid disorders? How many on Levothyroxine? Notice any difference between the two?
I have been on Synthroid for about 17 years --- I had a thyroid-ectomy when I was a teenager. my levels have never been consistant so my dosages changes rather often! I am now looking into one of the replacement hormones that has both T3 and T4 , that are all natural! Has anyone made the switch? and how did it work out for you?
I have been having okay results with Synthroid, but have done a lot of reading this week (Mary Shomon and Dr. Mark Starr), whose books advocate natural dessicated thyroid as more beneficial than synthetic thyroid. Before I ask my doctor to switch me, I'd like some opinions/experiences.
60mg (1 grain) NP Thyroid is unavailable most places right now. I talkked to the company and they said it would be back at pharmacies by end of June. I have been on it for over a year. I tracked down a pharmacy that still had some 60mg on hand and I noticed the smell is not as pungent as my last bottle-still trying to figure out what that means as the company also told me it has not been reformulated. This remains to be seen.
Would switching to the artificial thyroid rather than the natural make a difference? Would it eliminate the vertigo? BTW, heart was checked, everything is fine. The vertigo goes away and doesn't come back until I try going up again on the armour thyroid. I'm extra concerned because I still suffer, after 6 years, from hot flashes, (menopausal) which disturb my sleep. I'm cautious about the estradiol. Thanks so much!
I'm looking for a comparison in synthetic drug combos vs. natural thyroid replacement here. I swear I've tried more thyroid meds than a drug addict at this point (and could probably start my own pharmacy... Shhhh! Don't tell the FDA...:-O), but I've not yet tried Armour. Not sure what could possibly be the difference between the natural and the synthetic versions. Anyone have any experience they'd care to relay?
If your body likes a synthetic combination, the advantages are ease of availability and ease of adjusting T3 and T4 independently vs natural thyroid. Most people that have started natural thyroid in the last decade tried a synthetic combination in the past and weren't satisfied with the results. I wish a synthetic combo worked for me, but it doesn't do the job as well as Canadian natural thyroid by Erfa. Were all different.
There are many types of glandulars on the market. BUT the thyroid glandulars are not strong enough for actual thyroid disease....I know I tried them. They are considered a food supplement product and can be bought in health food stores. Unless they are getting thyroid meds from a different country or illegally......not good. Most likely they are talking about glandular products....
I recently had a complete Thyroidectomy and a Parathyroidectomy, is Synthroid the thyroid hormone supplement I should take, or natural? Has anyone had better results from Natural vs. Synthetic in regard to symthoms of being Hypothyroid?
How long were you on Synthroid? How long have you been taking Armour? What dosage was the Synthroid -- and now the Armour dosage? Explain what is going on? Like how you are feeling. Compare your symtpoms to us using both Synthroid and Armour? How did you feel on both meds? Where were your labs at prior to your switch? Are you being tested for the Free T3 and T4?
The Synthroid isn't the problem with depression but the thyroid hormone levels play a huge role in overcoming it. Research the T3 hormone and depression ( neurological) links.
There's a whole big controversy over "natural" vs. "synthetic", and sometimes the debate gets quite lively! I, personally, do not think one is better than the other. I'm on synthetic, but that's because I have a heart arrhythmia and can't take anything with T3 in it. Everyone has to experiment and see which works best for her. It's all very individual. I'm all for whatever works best for each of us.
Hello, I had thyroid cancer 5 years ago and was put on cytomel and synthroid. I am on 5mcg of cytomel and 300mcg of synthroid. I am exhausted, moody and still have to eat like a bird not to gain wt. Is this normal???? My labs are ok but something needs adjusted because I feel like poop. I do have alot of stress right now but I flucuate from being hyper and going non stop to crashing and feeling awful. any advice on dosage and or natural treatment would be great.
The best thyroid replacement is the one that works best for your body. Forget the natural vs synthetic argument, use what works for you. The standard is to try synthetic T4 meds first. Then if you need more T3, add cytomel to the mix. Still have symptoms ?(even if labs look great), then go with a dessicated product.
I used to take .275 synthroid. I have thyroid cancer and they completly removed the gland. My synthroid is used as a replacement therapy as well as a type of tumor supression so it is an absurdly high dose causing bad side effects. My thyroid gland was removed 15 years ago. I to had heart palpitations, shakes, insomnia the works. I did have some abnormal heart beats and the cardiologist wanted to do some procedure that involved an electrode thru a vein and zap some pathways in my heart.
This has no fillers or dyes and some people who could not take Levo or Synthroid did well with Tirosint 2) T3 only medication at least for a short time to hopefully give you some relief and help out with the RT3 issue 3) Natural Dissected Thyroid. This has both T3 and T4 in it. Also some people who did not do well with T4 only medication had good luck with this.
Still expericing severe lack of energy and hair loss,emotional swings,not tolerating stress well but each day gets a little better( but not as fast as I would like).I had no idea generic thyroid pills could be so bad. Please everyone check your thyroid meds because if I can help someone avoid what I have been through the past 2 mo it would be worth it.I would love to hear from anyone about their experiences following tt of generic pills.
After learning about the importance of Free T3 here on the Forum, I got mine tested and confirmed as low in the range. Got my doctor to switch my meds from Synthroid to Armour Thyroid. After some tweaking, I am now taking 3 grains of Armour. My Free T3 is now 3.9 (range of 2.3 - 4.2) and Free T4 is .84 (range of .60 - 1.50), and I feel best ever. For info my TSH has been around .05 or lower for about 30 years now.
Well, my new family doctor of 7 months said in one of our first appointments together she would give me "dessicated thyroid" if I didn't respond well to synthroid, which I am not. However, I asked her a few times to switch over and she almost acted like she didn't even hear me. Hmmm..? I'm going in with ammunition on Monday, documents supporting the switch to Amour and even a conversion chart!!! Less work for her might actually get me the switch.
I have changed endos and she is much easier to talk to and specializes in thyroid disorder. I also am starting this week on the new thyroid medicine Tirosint. It is synthroid in a gel cap with no additives. I would get pain every time I took my thyroid med and I hope this will stop that. Thank you for answering my post. This is a good place to air our concerns and to get the thoughts of others. I have learned alot on this site.
My wife has always been low or borderline low on her thyroid levels, and she's always been prescribed Synthroid or some other T4 pill. I was just looking over her most recent blood work, and decided to search the Internet for the meanings of some of the tests. I came across the T3 vs. T4 and TSH discussions on several sites; never knew there were all of those components.
MedHelp Health Answers