Mind you, I generally avoid ALL over-the-counter medications when it comes to acute migraine treatments because they all have the potential to cause rebound headaches and they all have the potential to trigger migraine headaches. Especially any product containing acetaminophen
and ibuprofen, this includes things like
Midrin and Excedrin.
Although, the problem here is that you have mentioned that you have had problems in the past with Triptans and my first suggestion is always triptans.