Depression medication vs talk therapy

Common Questions and Answers about Depression medication vs talk therapy


605458 tn?1539232408 Which would more likely cause weight gain? I went about most my life 'petite' until a lengthy depression hit and medication caused weight gain. I got quite obese for my size (168lbs at 5ft tall). I lost that weight a couple of years ago. It took me two years to do it right and I've kept it off. My psychiatrist knows to NEVER prescribe something that is known to cause weight gain. I read that the Lupron Depot can cause weight gain. What about a hysterectomy? Will you gain weight too?
306455 tn?1288865671 ” “The difference between eastern therapy and western therapy is like the difference between Chinese medication and western medication.” Time: GMT 12:00-2:00 PM, December 10th, 2007 (Monday) Platform: This forum will be held through a software called Team Speak, which is a quality, scalable application which enables people to speak with one another over the Internet. Go to, download the free client software, and connect to server’s address at:
Avatar m tn I'm new to this and my be speaking out of ignorance, but me and my MD felt a psychologist could help me with talk therapy and finding the root of my problem. A psychiatrist only on the other hand would be more interested in treating me with meds.....With that said, there may be some psychiatriasts who are psychologists and vice versa. Bottom line, you need to find someone that deals with people who have depression/anxiety issues because they will KNOW EXACTLY WHAT YOU ARE GOING THROUGH.
780665 tn?1239030149 Well of course a psychiatrist can prescribe medication. A psychologist is a talk therapist but sometimes works with a psychiatrist. Medication and talk therapy usually work best together though but as to whether you need treatment and what medication that would be up to the psychiatrist.
Avatar f tn My daughter is 18, and has been under medication and counseling for depression for five years. She used to cut, and has made more than one suicide attempt in the past, but is significantly better now. She is brilliant (I am not bragging), and has done remarkably well in her high school, which is highly regarded in our area. She has topped in the subject she loves most and wants to major in.
2064754 tn?1333379263 Many people medicate without a second opinion. Most don't even need the medication, they can go through other forms of therapy. Best of luck!
1143570 tn?1261223356 He also had many issues with depression and anger ...meds do help some but you also need therapy to deal with everything that has changed in your life since the injury. Its harder for you than the rest of us to control your anger and like you said to be able to find the right words to describe something...this is all possible and will come if you are willing to do some work and get someone who is qualified to help you...
Avatar n tn I was treated for depression after the first accident and prescibed prozac. I feel that this worked well. My husband doesn't believe in medications and thinks that I should just pull up my socks and get over it. I have recently been diagnosed as bi-polar. I am currently being prescribed zyp[rexa 2.5 mg twice a day. I was on heavy duty pain medication after another neck surgery (cervical denervation. After the surgery the pain become intolerable.
Avatar n tn SUBOXONE and SUBUTEX are part of a complete addiction treatment program that also includes counseling or behavioral therapy. SUBOXONE and SUBUTEX have not been studied in children. SUBOXONE is a tablet that contains 2 medicines. 1. The first medicine is called buprenorphine (BYOO-pruh-NOR-feen). It is like painkiller medicines such as morphine, street drugs like heroin, and addiction treatment medicines like methadone.
3199802 tn?1362254159 You infer that everyone has a cause for depression and therapy will address that. But, myself has no reason for depression. It just is. Therapy in UKdoes not exist as such. I have lots of counselling, which is probably the equavalent. Got nowhere, and had some stupid ideas put to me. Probably if people here need what you call "therapy" that would have to pay an amazing amount for it. People like me have what is called endogenous depression - ie there is no obvious reason for it.
20003388 tn?1515169640 If you just look at the science, it looks like a miracle, but in practice, it isn't -- it's an improvement over what we had before medication, maybe. As for the the theory of depression, the main area of current study is glutamate receptors, not dopamine or serotonin which are yesterday's news. Or at least right now, because yesterday's news in science can also be tomorrow's news when better studies are done.
2098127 tn?1333318623 I've changed my eating and exercise habits and I'd like to see if anyone else had had much success balancing moods naturally or what kind of experiences others have had with meds vs without...
Avatar f tn I just picked up your message after sending my last missive...maybe I should have read it first then I may have been able to condense my thoughts (not something that is easy for me, you may have noticed). I really thank you for you support. Typically, this has become a control issue for me that will always be a part of my life because that just the kind of person I am. Maybe I should have called myself Control Freak instead of Barfer...
Avatar m tn You should talk to your doctor about whether you are a good candidate for drug therapy or a clinical trial. Be sure that you understand the pros and cons of each treatment option. Whether you decide to start treatment or not, it is very important to be seen by a liver specialist or doctor knowledgeable about hepatitis B on a regular basis.
186166 tn?1385262982 Always feeling angry and lack of patience Depersonalization Depression Dramatic mood swings (emotional flipping) Emotionally blunted, flat, or numb Emotional "flipping" (dramatic mood swings) Emotions feel wrong Everything is scary, frightening Feeling down in the dumps Feeling like things are unreal or dreamlike Frequently being on edge or 'grouchy' Feel like crying for no apparent reason Have no feelings about things you used to Not feeling like yourself, detached fro
1551327 tn?1514049467 I can experience at times some standard concerns such as grandiosity and I work with my psychiatrist to have this addressed. Talk therapy is a key part of recovery as well. I am seeking to have more social functioning in my life which became impaired for a variety of reason, some known some more complex. The past years when medication didn't work or when it doesn't work as it should and my judgment can be impaired is frankly unnerving looking back.
Avatar n tn Overall I just roll with it and try and stay positive and I started to get acupuncture along with talk therapy. This week I will see my p-doc and I'm sure all of this will come up in my visit. Do you think Klonopin causes weight gain as well?
Avatar f tn I found the Zoloft to work at lowering my anxiety and depression but it made my tremor bad. I feel hopeless. I hope they all don't do that.
4149717 tn?1389507161 So i saw the Dr today (at the urging of my therapist) and he said in suffering from PTSD and depression and suggested some medication! I hear horror stories from people here about antidepressants so i wanted to get feed back from people on the 3 types he suggested. He suggested either Zoloft, Lexapro or Effexor. And in conjunction with those he also mentioned risperidol?
Avatar n tn most anxiety disorder can be helped enormously with a combination of medication such as a benzo and cognitive behavioral therapy. The research on Panic Disorder for instance, shows that using medication alone rarely if ever remits the symptoms over the long haul. Therapy alone, with no meds, works to alleviate and in many cases eradicate the episodes. It just tends to take longer without meds. Meds alone only aleviate the symptoms, they don't stop the problem.
443006 tn?1229205442 I wonder if anyone can offer any feedback regarding six-month (G2 and G3) treatment EOT depression vs. the typical one year (G1) Do G1's have more end of treatment symptoms than G2 and G3's due to the longer time on the drugs?
Avatar f tn It is great that every one has a defferent means of getting off the pills it gives new members alot of info to talk to there medical proffesional about. there is no one way but there is a wrong way and that is not to try every means out there to stop. I myself was sceptical about useing methadone to get off of hydro's but I was at the point of I would try almost anything and since the detox center I went had not gotten the clearance for suboxone yet they used methadone.
Avatar n tn I am taking wellbutrin and it has helped the depression plus it has given me a lot more energy.But to me the most important thing is I am opiate free.
Avatar f tn hemorrhoids (12% vs 3%), anorectal discomfort (11% vs 3%), anal pruritus (6% vs 1%) diarrhea (26% vs 17%) Anemia is a factor for both meds but there is always Procrit.... With Victrelis I like the idea of starting out with the Peg/Riba and then adding a medicine along the way rather than starting out with all three meds (with Incivek). I treated before and I can tell you It was incredibly overwhelming.
Avatar f tn I am a 15 year old girl and have been in therapy for depression, generalized anxiety, and borderline personality disorder since I was 9. I have also been on and off Prozac since then. Recently, my parents and I wanted a second opinion about increasing the dosage of my medication, so we went to a different psychiatrist than usual. This psychiatrist suggested that I might have been misdiagnosed and have mild Asperger's instead of BPD.
1415482 tn?1459706314 The best treatment for depression is a combination of lifestyle, medication, and talk therapy. Okay, no insurance for talk therapy---------- what about medication. Can you see a doctor for depression?? Can you take a medication. Newer antidepressents are pretty tolerable and often benefit outweighs side effects. In your case, I think it is essential to get rid of any chemical issues within your brain to help you deal with trying to move to a new phase and have a happy life.
Avatar n tn Funny how no one ever mentions physical therapy.
Avatar n tn I think I've gotten all I can out this type of therapy. My psychologist likes to talk about his vacations, dinners and hobbies; mountainbiking and photography. I think he gets more out the sessions than I do. Kind thanks for any suggestions.