If you have a FNA biopsy and get an indeterminate result, you will have to remove the
thyroid to get a diagnosis. Many times they cannot see
cancer until the
thyroid is out and examined by a pathologist. Barb is right, no problem living without a thyroid, but living with cancer is another story! The nodules will not go away, you will probably lose thyroid function eventually, as my doctor/brother told me, do it now when you are young and get it over with!